1. First, check: are you eligible?
Check eligibility before you write anything, so you do not draft a proposal in vain. Taking the SBIR website's FAQ as an example:
- You must meet the definition of a small or medium-sized enterprise: paid-in capital or contributed capital of NT$100 million or less, or fewer than 200 regular employees.
- You cannot apply if there is investment from mainland China, if you have unpaid taxes owed within the past three years, or if you have a record of serious breach of a government program or procurement contract within the past five years.
- Newly established companies and companies with foreign shareholding may also apply if they meet the conditions, but they may not be mainland Chinese-owned or a Taiwan branch of a foreign for-profit company.
- In principle, one company or one responsible person can carry out only one project at a time.
Eligibility is a question of whether you qualify, not of how well you write. We recommend checking this first.
2. The process at a glance
SBIR applications are made online: you fill in the application form in the online system, write the proposal (or prepare a presentation, depending on the phase), and upload the required documents. After submission, the proposal goes through review by a panel of reviewers and is then approved by the Ministry of Economic Affairs, which decides whether it passes. Approved projects move on to contracting and execution.
The program is divided into phases: Phase 1 (preliminary research), Phase 2 (research and development) and Phase 2+ (value-added application). In general, an applicant must complete the previous phase first. A project that already fits the spirit of R&D may apply directly for Phase 2 without Phase 1, and Phase 2+ must be submitted within 3 years after the previous project is closed. SBIR currently accepts applications online all year round, with no submission deadline. That is how SBIR works, however; other subsidy programs often have fixed submission periods, so check each program's announcement.
In addition, once the review meeting has ended, no further supplementary material is accepted, so prepare all your documents in one go before submitting.
3. Common sticking points (1): unclear innovation and no comparison
The SBIR website publishes the "common patterns of proposals not recommended." We have summarized several of them:
- The innovation cannot be explained: the core technology is regarded as mature, or is merely an improvement on an existing product, and the proposal does not explain what is new in the system, process, function or specification.
- No comparison with existing solutions: the proposal does not compare technology, performance, stability or price with similar domestic or foreign products, so reviewers cannot see where the improvement lies.
- Insufficient preliminary results: preliminary research data is missing, or the preliminary results have little to do with the work now proposed, making it hard to show the work can be done.
In plain terms: it is not "we will build something great," but "how others do it today, how we are different, and what evidence we have."
4. Common sticking points (2): vague targets, and budget and document details
- Targets and checkpoints that are too vague: patterns listed by the authority include checkpoints without quantified targets, no explanation of technical risks and how they will be handled, and execution steps described only in outline.
- All key technology outsourced: if the core technology is entirely outsourced and there is no explanation of how the company will take it over later, the company's own capability is easily judged insufficient.
- Small budget and document details: the subsidy may not exceed 50% of the total project cost; if the company's own contribution is larger than its paid-in capital, proof of a financial plan is required; and the latest labor insurance roster must be provided before the review meeting. These are items that are easy to discover only at the last minute.
5. Before you seek help, know these boundaries
The SBIR website's solemn statement reads: "This program has never commissioned any consulting or agency company to assist companies in submitting proposals, or even guarantee approval, in exchange for any payment. Do not trust messages from the internet, consulting companies or other private individuals, to avoid loss of personal data or money." The website's FAQ also explains that where a consultant is involved, outsourcing fees may not include fees for proposal coaching, or for writing the proposal, presentation, or interim and final reports.
So our position is simple: whether a proposal is approved is decided by the competent authority's review, and we do not guarantee approval. What we can do, before you start, is clarify your eligibility, your current processes and your data, so that the content of your proposal has a basis, and confirm that it is consistent with each requirement in the announcement.
Fees are also stated up front: the free subsidy quick screening and the 30-minute first consultation are free of charge. If you then want our help, we quote case by case according to the scope of work, and before quoting we list in writing what will be done and at what price. What we charge for is consulting work such as eligibility review, organizing current processes and data, and preparing supply-chain documents. We do not charge for writing the proposal, and we do not charge any "guaranteed approval" fee.
Further reading: Why Quotes for the Same Requirement Differ So Much: Five Places to Check in a Comparison Table